March 1, 2017 Updated April 23, 2018 By Sam 68 Comments
Skip the store-bought, pre-packaged graham cracker crusts and make your own! A good graham cracker crust takes only a few ingredients and several minutes to make, with this solid, simple recipe you’ll never need to buy a storebought crust again!
I kind of understand the hesitation to make your own pie crust when it comes to traditional pastry crusts. I know the frustration of trying to roll out a perfectly circular crust, of sprinkling flour over your whole counter-top to keep things from sticking, and the annoyance of cleaning up afterwards.
I always opt to make my own crusts, but I can at least understand why someone might choose the pre-packaged variety.
But when it comes to graham cracker crusts, I really feel that there’s no excuse to ever buy one from the store. For one, they don’t taste nearly as good as one that you could make yourself, and secondly they are so supremely simple to make that it’s almost laughable.
Today I want to walk through the simple steps to make your own graham cracker crust. The whole process takes about five minutes, and once you have this recipe I have a feeling you’re going to avoid the storebought crusts from now on.
We start with graham crackers. Alternatively, pre-crumbled graham cracker crumbs. You’ll need approximately 10 graham cracker sheets, which translates to 1 1/2 cups of graham cracker crumbs.
Process them in a food processor or place them in a large ziploc use and bag a rolling pin to pulverize them into fine, sandy crumbs, like below:
Add your sugar — I like to use a split of both white sugar and brown sugar, but you can use just one or the other if you would like. I feel that the brown sugar gives it a slightly richer flavor (something you don’t get from a semi-stale storebought crust! ).
Next comes the butter, which essentially acts as the glue that holds the whole crust together.
Use a fork to toss everything together. I prefer to use a fork rather than a spoon or a spatula because it does a good job of evenly incorporating everything together.
After a little bit of mixing, the crumb mixture should be well-combined and slightly damp.
Now you’re ready to transfer everything to your pie plate. This graham cracker crust recipe also works for cheesecake in a 9 or 10 springform pan, even though
You can use a 9 pie plate, which I used here.
Transfer your crumbs to your pie plate and press them tightly into the bottom of the pan. I like to use the (clean) bottom of one of my measuring cups to press the crumbs — it makes for a smooth, even surface.
Finally, tend to the sides of the pie crust. Use your fingers to press the crumbs firmly all around the sides of the pie pan.
Your graham cracker crust will need to be baked in order to firm it up, that way when you cut into your pie the crust cuts nicely and doesn’t crumble. Just follow the instructions in your recipe if your recipe is one that requires baking the pie. You can just slip it into the fridge or freezer for a few minutes before using,
If it is for a no-bake recipe.
And that is it! Just a few super simple steps to your own homemade graham cracker crust.
Full recipe just below the video